Showing posts with label Research. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Research. Show all posts

Tuesday, August 26, 2025

How will Genealogy Research be Different in the Future?

    How much has genealogy research changed over the past 50 years? Or even history, for that matter. Think about it. Fifty years ago would have been the year 1975. Computers weren't available for research. (Microsoft was founded in 1975) To access documents like census records, you would have had to go to the library and page through censuses on microfilm. No index. No search feature. No shaky little leaves on Ancestry. Actually, Ancestry.com wasn't even around at this time.

They didn't become a company until 1983. So all your records would have been on paper, on microfilm, and in libraries. Seasoned researchers would tell us we have it easy today. Years ago, people never expected access would be available for specific documents. The birth of the internet in 1983 has changed all this. Every day, documents are digitized and made available to the public. 


A Year In History - 1975 Archives


    But have you given any thought to how genealogy research will be different in the future? Let's say another 50 years? That would put us in the year 2100. Most of us won't be here anymore. So what will be available? What will be different? What won't be available? What records can we access that wouldn't have been available 100 years ago?
    I sat down and talked with my adult child (they are now 21) about this topic. Life is definitely different from what it was in 1975. To learn more about the statistical information from 1975, head over to Census.gov, and you can compare differences from then to today. 


National News: Adults are now struggling to hit these four milestones, Census Says


So, I asked my child what they thought would be available and how research would be different in light of the changes our society has undergone.

Here are some topics that are different in society today and how they do/will impact our research:

  • More people are having kids without getting married
  • More people are having multiple partners with multiple kids
  • Polyamorous Relationships (maybe marriages one day)
    • How will these facts affect research?
    • DNA will play a bigger part
  • Changing of names
    • Different names used in censuses, obituaries, newspapers, etc.
    • Might make it more difficult to trace ancestors
  • Changing of genders
    • Multiple genders
    • Legal and surgical
  • Marriages between the same gender
    • Know the state laws and policies
    • People could have gone to other states to get married and live
    Depending on the topic, more sources will be available to support the results. The question about changing genders and same-sex marriages came up in my beginner genealogy class a couple of years ago. While this wasn't something that was addressed back 50 years ago as much as it is now, it's something we need to start thinking about when it comes to records and sources. But the same format will still be used for checking the validity. If there's no record or source to support the claim or the story, then it's not proven to be true. (See the Genealogical Proof Standard.) So it's necessary to start saving information with proof for future researchers.
    In the future, we will have access to more and different records than we've had available to us in the past. In an age where the internet runs our lives, there is almost nothing we can't access or learn about someone. And with the changing of how we live our lives, more records are kept that weren't available 50 years ago.

What different records or sources will be available that weren't in the past?
  • Credit Reports (Currently only available to the named person or, if they have passed, a legal representative or executor)
  • Medical Records (Currently only available to the named person, or family if permission was granted in writing)
  • Social Media Accounts
    • Able to download data
    • Can designate a person to take over the account after death
  • Driving Records (Available to the public without personal information)
  • Cloud Access
  • Cell phone data
  • Email Accounts
  • More access to out-of-the-country records
  • Social Security Records - the use of a Social Security number has changed quite a bit since its creation
  • Employment Records - more employers keep detailed files on past employees
    As you can see, some records are available ONLY to the named person, or to a descendant who is an executor, has a court order, or is in the paperwork. With the creation of new records comes new privacy laws. Before, we mostly dealt with the fact that census records were only released every 72 years, birth records were unavailable in some states until 100 years after the event, and sealed adoption records. Today, identity theft is a major concern, and efforts are being made to make personal data harder to access. Which is great! Unfortunately, it may also affect how we research in the future. So it's important to prepare.

    Now, with all these changes, some records won't include the same data they used to, or some records will become obsolete. Newspapers used to be a great source of information about our ancestors' lives (they still are for the past), but now, with rising costs and privacy concerns, you are lucky if an obituary was published that included any family. And more and more publishing companies are producing less paper and opting for digital formats.

What records or sources may not be available, may change, or may be obsolete?
  • City Directories (They are phasing out for privacy concerns)
  • Immigration records may not be as accessible
  • Passenger lists
  • Census Records will be asking different questions
  • Newspapers are changing 
    • They don't share as much information as they used to because of privacy concerns
    • Cost of publishing obituaries can be astronomical, so more people are not even publishing one
    • Leaning towards more digital formats and not printed formats
  • Marriage bonds - "A man would file a marriage bond to legally affirm his intention to marry a particular woman and confirm there was no legal impediment to the marriage." - Family Tree Magazine

    Now you may be asking, why focus on what will be available in the future when genealogy research is focusing on the past? Good question! Thinking about how things will be different will help us determine what we should save today for future researchers. As stated above, some sources are only available to executors or those with a court order. So we need to start today. Save copies of documents, sources, information, or anything you think will be important.

There are a few books written that address saving items for future generations and how to downsize. I recommend the following:


    I've been a genealogy researcher since 2012; not as long as others, and in that short time, I've seen many changes in how we research. It's causing me to approach my own research differently. We all need to start collecting, digitizing, and preserving our history for the future. Based on what we have seen over the last 50 years, we don't know what's going to be accessible or available to us. So prepare now. 

How do you think Genealogy Research will be different in the future?
Leave your comments below.
I'd love to hear your thoughts.



Tuesday, July 1, 2025

How Newspapers Can Lead to Other Sources

     One of my favorite sources to browse is newspapers, as you probably guessed. As a birthday and Christmas gift from my mom, I have a subscription to Newspapers.com. I visit this site almost every day, not only to track down ancestors and information about their lives but also to explore local history. You can learn a wealth of information about the era your ancestors lived in as it was happening. Historical events like The Great Depression, World Wars I & II, the moon landing, and much more. But that's a story for another time.

    When I start researching a new family member, couple, or family line, after entering some basic details into my tree, I go to newspapers.com to see what information appears. Depending on the year and location, you can find quite a few clues for additional sources. Newspapers were known for publishing a lot of personal information, especially if it involved court cases. And it's these published details that can help you discover more documents, sources, and information about your ancestor. So, let's look at some examples.

Marriages
Licenses - When licenses were obtained, they were listed in the newspaper with the date the license was acquired. This will lead you to the license itself. 

Marriage License - Edward Hilke & Mary Schulling
Marriage License
Edward Hilke & Mary Schulling

11 Mar 1904, Fri
The Journal-Democrat
(Warrensburg, Missouri)

Newspapers.com
Marriage of Bunch / Krumsick
Marriage of Bunch / Krumsick
08 Nov 1912, Fri
The Alma Enterprise
(Alma, Kansas)

Newspapers.com

Engagements/Announcements/Showers - These will include more details about the couple, including parents' names, friends, a church, or addresses. If a church is named, you might be able to acquire a copy of the church register. From there, depending on the church, the register might also include baptism information, which could then lead to finding a copy of the baptismal certificate. Addresses could be used to confirm family in census records and city directories.

Surprise Shower for Pearl McGrew
Surprise Shower for Pearl McGrew
02 May 1932, Mon
The Maryville Daily Forum
(Maryville, Missouri)

Newspapers.com
McGrew-Swope Marriage
McGrew-Swope Marriage
03 May 1932, Tue
The Maryville Daily Forum
(Maryville, Missouri)

Newspapers.com

Wedding Details - This will usually be shared after the wedding has taken place. It can include names of the wedding party and their relationship, parents, the location where the wedding took place (whether a house or church), and even who officiated the wedding. If an announcement hadn't been published, this could be just as helpful to track down more sources and documents. 

Nancy Ann Seidel weddingNancy Ann Seidel Wedding
18 Apr 1973, Wed
St. Louis Post-Dispatch
(St. Louis, Missouri)

Newspapers.com

Births
These are hit and miss but can still be helpful with adding a birth year to your tree. Names of the children are not always given, but the names of the parents are given. This can lead to birth records and baptismal records.

Birth Recorded - Valdes
Birth Recorded
J R Valdes

8223 Michigan
21 Jun 1938, Tue
St. Louis Post-Dispatch
(St. Louis, Missouri)

Newspapers.com
Jerry Valdes Birth
Jerry Valdes Birth
21 Jun 1938, Tue
The St. Louis Star and Times
(St. Louis, Missouri)

Newspapers.com

Deaths
There are quite a few articles that you could look for that can help with the death information of an ancestor.

Obituaries
- these can be a treasure trove of information about an ancestor's life and their relations. Also the location of the burial. This can lead to death certificates, church registers for deaths and burials, burial permits, and possible funeral home records. Depending on how detailed the obituary is about the ancestor could lead to other records such as military, marriage records, city directories, and more. 

Obituary for ALBERTA V. Huerner
Obituary
ALBERTA V. Huerner

01 Feb 1978, Wed
St. Louis Post-Dispatch
(St. Louis, Missouri)

Newspapers.com
Obituary for LOUISE K. Strawhun
Obituary
LOUISE K. Strawhun

20 Feb 1971, Sat
St. Louis Post-Dispatch
(St. Louis, Missouri)

Newspapers.com
Obituary for Wilbert H.Obituary
Wilbert H. "Buck" Strawhun

27 Aug 1979, Mon
St. Louis Post-Dispatch
(St. Louis, Missouri)

Newspapers.com

Burial Permits - Not every city requires one, but St. Louis did. I've had quite a bit of luck with burial permits thanks to newspapers publishing the list. This is especially helpful if an ancestor died before death certificates were standardized. 

Louise Strawhun Burial Permit
Louise Strawhun Burial Permit
25 Feb 1971, Thu
St. Louis Post-Dispatch
(St. Louis, Missouri)

Newspapers.com
Robert Strawhun Burial Permit
Robert Strawhun Burial Permit
22 Nov 1970, Sun
St. Louis Post-Dispatch
(St. Louis, Missouri)

Newspapers.com

Card of Thanks/In Memoriam - Families of the deceased will sometimes submit a card of thanks for the newspaper to run to thank all those who called upon them during their time of grief, which can include organizations there were a member of and even the funeral home where you can contact for records as well. This will connect the deceased to the living family. Or sometimes they will publish an In Memoriam of the deceased. If you don't have a death date, this may be the only hint you have to try to locate more sources. 

In Memoriam of Edward Sleets
In Memoriam of Edward Sleets
20 Dec 1963, Fri
The St. Louis Argus
(St. Louis, Missouri)

Newspapers.com
Card of Thanks - Edward J Buer
Card of Thanks
Edward J Buer

10 Feb 1929, Sun
St. Louis Post-Dispatch
(St. Louis, Missouri)

Newspapers.com

Notice of Letters/Administrative Notes - When an ancestor dies without a will, their estate is processed through the Probate Court. An executor will run a notice in the newspaper for anyone who has an account to settle with the decedent. This will not only tell you that your ancestor has passed away, but that you should look for a probate record. Now, these can go on for years, so keep that in mind when you are trying to determine the date of death.

Z. T. McGrew estate
Z. T. McGrew estate
16 Dec 1915, Thu
The Blackwell Weekly Sun
(Blackwell, Oklahoma)

Newspapers.com
Administrator's Notice - Sophia Buer
Administrator's Notice
Nicholas Buer

21 Oct 1870, Fri
Jefferson Democrat
(Hillsboro, Missouri)

Newspapers.com

Special Articles - If this were a case that had special circumstances, depending on what happened, you might find a court case if it was a murder, or you might find coroner records if the death was suspicious.

Inquests Held in deaths of three killed by trainsInquests Held in deaths of three killed by trains
28 Sep 1934, Fri
Sedalia Weekly Democrat (Sedalia, Missouri)
Newspapers.com

Property/Real Estate Transfers
These announcements will mention the names and possible property location. This will lead you to the deed paperwork. And if the location is given, you can look up the property on plat maps.

Real Estate Transfer from Bogert to Otte
Real Estate Transfer
Bogert to Otte

08 Sep 1960, Thu
Washington Missourian
(Washington, Missouri)

Newspapers.com
Transfer of Real Estate from Morton Jackson to Charles Yancy
Transfer of Real Estate
Morton Jackson to Charles Yancy

10 Jun 1886, Thu
Union Record
(Union, Missouri)

Newspapers.com

Court Cases
These can be as simple as name vs. name or a whole newspaper article about the event that took place. This will lead to court records. Sometimes they will have court cases listed under headings such as Probate Court Docket or Circuit Court Docket. Other records you could locate based on the articles: divorce records, guardianship records, custody records, or penitentiary records (if convicted).

George Sleet charged with assault
George Sleet charged with assault
14 Aug 1936, Fri
The Gerald Journal
(Gerald, Missouri)

Newspapers.com
Divorce - Winnie Yancy vs. William Yancy
Divorce
Winnie Yancy vs. William Yancy

25 Jul 1924, Fri
Franklin County Tribune
(Union, Missouri)

Newspapers.com
Probate Court Docket - Sleets, heirs, minors, Richard Lane, gd (guardian)
Probate Court Docket
Sleets, heirs, minors, Richard Lane, gd (guardian)

28 Oct 1910, Fri
Washington Citizen
(Washington, Missouri)

Newspapers.com
Flossie Peterson vs George Fuchs, suit on note
Flossie Peterson vs George Fuchs
suit on note

10 Nov 1960, Thu
Jefferson County Record
(Hillsboro, Missouri)

Newspapers.com


Military Records
Depending on the article, it can lead you to many different military records.

  • If your ancestor was drafted, his name and number could be in the newspaper, as that was sometimes the best way to notify a person quickly. That draft number can lead you to transport records and military files. 
  • If your ancestor went to basic training somewhere or graduated, you might find records from that training facility or locate a yearbook. Ft. Leonard Wood had yearbooks for its graduates. (See my website)
  • If your ancestor was KIA, there could be a Burial Case File at the National Archives. 
  • If they were captured and a prisoner of war, there could be prisoner of war records. 
  • If letters were sent home, you could check with family members if anyone has them or remembers details from the letters. 
  • And of course, if their unit was listed in the newspaper, you can look up information about that particular unit, including maps from the battles they participated in. 

World War I Draft Drawing
World War I Draft Drawing
12 Oct 1918, Sat
Carthage Evening Press
(Carthage, Missouri)

Newspapers.com
Killed in Action - William Ilg
Killed in Action
William Ilg

20 Dec 1918, Fri
Columbia Missourian
(Columbia, Missouri)

Newspapers.com
Frank Marquart Jr finishes basic at Ft. Leonard Wood
Frank Marquart Jr finishes
basic at Ft. Leonard Wood

26 Sep 1957, Thu
Franklin County Tribune
(Union, Missouri)

Newspapers.com
Captain Joseph H Rickards arrived
Capt Joseph Rickards, 12th Calvary
26 Sep 1863, Sat
The St. Joseph Herald
(St. Joseph, Missouri)

Newspapers.com

Organization Membership
Some organizations have memberships and keep records. These organizations will sometimes list the names of their members and if they hold certain positions. This can lead to documents and records.

GAR Elect officers - Wm McKinley Post 324
GAR Elect officers
Wm McKinley Post 324

16 Dec 1904, Fri
Sullivan Sentinel
(Sullivan, Missouri)

Newspapers.com

Schools
Graduations, school programs, conerts, theater, etc will lead you to possible school records or at the very least the name of the school your ancestor attended. Then you might be able to find yearbooks.

Writing Rags to Riches Story at Northwest High School - Dennis Fuchs
Writing "Rags to Riches" Story at Northwest High School - Dennis Fuchs
27 Oct 1960, Thu Jefferson County Record (Hillsboro, Missouri) Newspapers.com

Businesses
If your ancestor ran a business, it could appear in the newspaper for many reasons. Which can lead to business licenses, addresses that can be used to locate on a map or in city directories. Even tax papers. If your ancestor owned a farm and operated a dairy business, cattle business, etc., these articles could lead you to farm censuses. Plus, check with local historical societies if they have any information about your ancestors. They receive items all the time related to businesses and farms.

Moonlight Tavern, Thomas FuchsMoonlight Tavern
Thomas Fuchs

25 Apr 1940, Thu
The Ellington Press
(Ellington, Missouri)

Newspapers.com


I hope this gave you additional ideas on how to use newspapers to find more sources and documents. I can't tell you how many times newspapers.com has been helpful. Time to dive back into my research!

Do you have any other tips on how useful Newspapers can be when researching your family?



Thursday, May 16, 2024

Applying for a Social Security Number with no Birth Certificate?

     I know you are looking at this title and thinking, "How does someone not have a birth certificate or access to one these days?" And you would be right to think that. But back in 1884/1885 when my 2nd Great-Grandma, Oma Mae Dennis was born, they didn't issue certificates like today. You were lucky to have any proof of when you were born. So if you don't have a birth certificate, how do you apply for a Social Security Number to receive benefits? That was the question I asked myself and my trusted Genealogy Facebook group GAA (Genealogy Addicts Anonymous). With everyone's help and my own research, we came up with some answers. Let's get into it.

History of Birth Certificates
    First, let's start with some history about Birth Certificates. Would you believe that the recording of births was not standardized until around the 1930s? Before then, it was up to the local counties and churches to keep their own records. And their records were only as good as the people providing the information. You see, most births occurred at home with a midwife (or doctor sometimes) present. Only if a child was baptized in the church would it be recorded. If, by chance, the doctor was present, he would record this information in his notes and give it to the county. Otherwise, it was still up to the family to report the birth to the county. 
    As you can see, there would be plenty of chances for a birth to not be recorded. The only other way to know a child had been born to the family was through Census records. The government began conducting censuses of the population in 1790, but the information was not very detailed until the 1850 census.  Even so, it wasn't until 1902 that Congress enacted a legislative bill for the Census Bureau to have a permanent office within the Department of the Interior. This is when the recording of Vital Statistics would start to become more standardized.

Accordingly, in 1902, when the U.S. Bureau of the Census was made a permanent agency of the federal government, the legislation authorized the director of the Bureau to obtain, annually, copies of records filed in the vital statistics offices of those states and cities having adequate death registration systems and to publish data from these records. A few years earlier, the Bureau had issued a recommended death reporting form (the first “U.S. Standard Certificate of Death”) and requested each independent registration area to adopt it as of January 1, 1900. Those areas that adopted the form and whose death registration was 90 percent com plete were to be included in a national death-registration area that had been established in 1880. In 1915 the national birth-registration area was established, and by 1933 all states were registering live births and deaths with acceptable event coverage and providing the required data to the Bureau for the production of national birth and death statistics. - National Library of Medicine 1

    Since many wouldn't have had birth certificates when the Social Security Administration went into effect, I knew there had to be some information provided to the public telling them what they needed to do. I came across an article published by Good Housekeeping in September 1942. Many soldiers were having trouble registering for the military in World War II because they didn't have proof of their birth in the United States. So Good Housekeeping wrote an article on the importance of having a Birth Certificate and how to get one. 

Good Housekeeping
September 1942
Page 32
Cornell University Library

No Birth Certificate: Now what?
    My 2nd Great-Grandma, Oma Mae Dennis was not issued a birth certificate in 1884/1885. So that was an issue. So I began to look at other options for proof of birth for her. 

Birth Registers - If you were lucky, your ancestors lived in or near a big city. This would give you more of a chance to find a register of births. For the city of St. Louis, Ancestry.com has birth registers going back to the 1850s. Below is a birth register for my Great-Grandpa Joseph Ilg. He was born in 1899 in St. Louis, Missouri.

Missouri, US, Birth Registers
St. Louis, Missouri
Ilg, John (Joseph)
Ancestry.com

Church Registers - Another option was locating the church the family attended. Odds are you will find a baptismal register if the church conducted baptisms. Below is a baptismal register for the same Great-Grandpa above, Joseph Ilg. The family attended St. Boniface Church in Carondelet, Missouri. This register was not on Ancestor nor was it with the church. The copies were held at the St. Louis County Library Headquarters. Not all registers will have a birth date listed, but this one register had a column for birth dates.

St. Boniface Church
Baptismal Register
St. Louis County Library Headquarters

Family Bibles - During my years of research, I learned that Bibles were considered a primary source of birth, marriage, and death information. The majority of the time this was the only record that proved when an ancestor was born. This was foreign to me as my family did not keep records that way. My mom and my grandma kept little date books. While going through boxes, I was fortunate to locate a datebook belonging to my 2nd Great-Grandma, Pauline Ilg. She kept records of all her children's births and deaths, plus marriage and immigration information. Below are images of a family bible from the Wheeler Family and Grandma Pauline Ilg's datebook.

Wheeler Family Bible
Births
Originals Held by Kyle Smith (Cousin)


Family Date Book
Ruth Wheeler Collection

Delayed Birth Certificate - I first learned Bibles could be used as a primary source when I located a Delayed Birth Certificate for my Great-Grandpa James B. Wheeler. When the registration of births started to become more standard and it was more necessary to show proof of birth, the Delayed Filing Registration came about. This was especially the case when the Social Security Administration began requiring proof of birth in the United States before they would issue a Social Security Number and offer benefits. Below is the Delayed Birth Certificate for Great-Grandpa James B. Wheeler. Notice the evidence supplied to prove his date and location of birth.

Tennessee, US Delayed Birth Records, 1869-1909
Birth Certificates, April 1878
James Benjamin Francis Wheeler
Ancestry.com

    Once I learned about Delayed Birth Certificates, I assumed that was what my 2nd Great-Grandma, Oma Mae Dennis, used to obtain a Social Security Number. This was the #1 suggestion from the members of the GAA Facebook group. I poured over all the Delayed Birth Certificates issued in Tennessee the year she was born with no luck. I even checked years before and after just in case the year was recorded wrong. There were some discrepancies about her birth that I won't get into right now, but unfortunately, this didn't clear them up.

No Delayed Birth Certificate: Strike two!
    So my question was, "How was she able to get a Social Security Number?" This is what I posted in the Facebook group. Among the people who commented were some past employees of the Social Security Administration. They provided excellent information regarding what they were allowed to accept as proof of birth.

Comment from member of GAA

    I also checked Newspapers.com for any articles about applying for Social Security Benefits. To my surprise, there were a few articles. They provided details on how to apply for benefits and what forms of identification they would accept.

The Chillicothe Constitution-Tribune
(Chillicothe, Missouri)
9 Aug 1965, Mon · Page 7
Newspapers.com
The Chillicothe Constitution-Tribune
(Chillicothe, Missouri)
9 Aug 1965, Mon · Page 7
Newspapers.com



So What Did She Use??
    I was hoping when I sent off to get her original application from the Social Security Administration, it would provide the forms of identification she used to get a Social Security Number and collect benefits but it did not. It makes me question what she actually used because the birth information listed on the application, the one SHE filled out, was wrong. Granted, the documents and sources I collected are a little sketchy. Her death certificate had a birth date of January 11, 1884. The original court records of her adoption (yes, she was adopted) state her birth date being January 11, 1885. Then the Social Security Application has her birth date as January 11, 1889. 

    According to the newspaper articles, Oma could have used her marriage records and/or divorce records to prove her age. That would be the only thing to my knowledge that should have had in her possession unless they got access to census records, which is also possible. So to be frank, I have no clue what she used, but whatever the case, she did get a Social Security number and collected benefits.

Do you have an interesting story about getting a Social Security number? I've surely read a few thanks to the GAA Facebook group. Share yours in the comments. Also if you have any questions about this topic, post them in the comments as well. I hope you learned something new after reading this. If you did, let me know. 

I'll end this post with a funny article I came across while researching this topic. Apparently, more women were not honest about their ages than I originally thought. So much so, that an article was published about it when it came to collecting social security. 

St. Louis Post-Dispatch
(St. Louis, Missouri)
26 Mar 1950, Sun · Page 1
Newspapers.com





Sources:
1: National Research Council (US) Committee on National Statistics. Vital Statistics: Summary of a Workshop. Washington (DC): National Academies Press (US); 2009. B, The U.S. Vital Statistics System: A National Perspective. Available from: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK219884/

2: United States Census Bureau, History: Census History Staff, Revised December 14, 2003 ("https://www.census.gov/history/www/reference/legislation/legislation_1902_-_1941.html": accessed 15 May 2024)

3: United States Census Bureau, Agency History ("https://www.census.gov/history/www/census_then_now/": accessed 15 May 2024)

4: US Birth Certificates, The History of Birth Certificates: US Birth Certificates Team ("https://www.usbirthcertificates.com/articles/history-birth-certificates" accessed 15 May 2024

5: Brumberg HL, Dozor D, Golombek SG. History of the birth certificate: from inception to the future of electronic data. J Perinatol. 2012 Jun;32(6):407-11. doi: 10.1038/jp.2012.3. Epub 2012 Feb 2. PMID: 22301527.

6: John Waggoner. Key Moments in the History of Social Security, AARP, 11 Apr 2023 ("https://www.aarp.org/retirement/social-security/info-2020/social-security-history-timeline.html" accessed 15 May 2024)

7: Good Housekeeping. Home Economics Archive: Research, Tradition and History. Hearst Corp, New York. Digital Copies held by Cornell University, Digital Collections, https://digital.library.cornell.edu/catalog/hearth6417403 

Tuesday, December 7, 2021

Passenger Lists - How Do We Know Which Database to Search?

     How do you find out when your ancestors came to America and how do you find the passenger list they were on? These were questions that were posed to me the other day. The easiest answer would be to search the Passenger Lists database on Ancestry to see if anything comes up. But more than likely there will be multiple entries for the name you are searching for. So how do you determine which one is the correct entry? There are a couple of places to look for clues that will help you narrow down that information and find the correct passenger list.

EMS Ship
1887
Ancestry.com
2nd Great-Grandma Pauline Kimmerle
emigrated from Germany on this ship

Census Records

The first place to check is the census records. Some censuses have more information than others, but you can always glean something from them. Here is what you can find in each census.

1880 - Place of birth for parents
If they are born from another country, that will tell you where your ancestors would have come from.

1900 - Place of birth for parents, Year of immigration to US, No. of years in US, and Naturalization
There is an actual Citizenship section on this census. The year of immigration helps narrow down the time period to look for passenger lists. Just keep in mind that this could be wrong depending on who gave the information. Check other census records to compare the dates. The Naturalization column will tell you if they are Naturalized. If they are, you can check for that paperwork. 

1900 US Federal Census
Ancestry.com

1910, 1920, 1930 - Same as 1900

1940 - Place of birth and whether the Ancestor was a citizen or not. They are from a foreign country, column 16 will have one of the following: Na, Pa, Al, Na Cit, or 4. (See my blog post about Citizenship of Foreign Born - 1940 Census)

1940 US Federal Census
Ancestry.com

1950 (Released April 2022) - Same as 1940; Be sure to check the Supplemental Questions for more information.

This is just a start. The census records will give you clues on where to look next to find immigration information and records. 

Naturalization Records

When someone wants to become a Naturalized Citizen of the United States, there are a few different stages they have to go through. Through these stages, applications are filled out and certain information is given. This information will help you find when they came to the United States, what ship they traveled on, and sometimes the name of the village they came from. To learn more about Naturalization and Immigration records, visit the National Archives Website.

Case Study: Declaration of Intention Record - Martin Hribar
When a person wants to become a Naturalized Citizen, the first application they have to fill out is called a Declaration of Intention Record, also known as First Papers. Martin Hribar is the immigrant ancestor for my friend and her family. On the 1920 Census, in Columns 13, 14, and 15, it states that Martin Hribar was Naturalized, the year he was Naturalized, and when he Immigrated.

1920 US Federal Census
Ancestry.com
Martin Hribar - Beaver Dam, Butler, Missouri

This would mean he would have filled out a Declaration of Intention Record. On this record, it lists where Martin came from when he arrived in the United States. This will lead to the ship manifest.

Declaration of Intention Record
26 April 1906
FamilySearch.org
Martin Hribar

Passport Applications

Passports were issued for foreign travel for a few different reasons and the applications that were filled out contained a plethora of information regarding the immigration of the applicant. Information such as Birthdate, the village of birth, the date of immigration, the ship name, and when they were naturalized. 

Case Study: Passport Application - George Hilke
George Hilke is my husband's 2nd Great Grand Uncle; he is the brother of my husband's 2nd Great Grandfather. In order to learn more about the family, sometimes it's necessary to research the siblings of your direct ancestors. The passport application of George Hilke provided the village the family came from along with the immigration information. The biggest piece of information on this application is the name of the ship and the date they traveled. That will lead you directly to a ship manifest.

Passport Application
6 April 1896
Ancestry.com
George Hilke

Passenger Lists

Once you have some basic information, you can search on Ancestry.com or FamilySearch.org for ship manifests and passenger lists. Most people think that their ancestors came through Ellis Island, and while that may be true, that's not the first port that immigrants came through. Ellis Island was in operation from 1892-1950 so if your ancestor immigrated before 1892, they would have come through Castle Garden, like my 2nd Great-Grandma Pauline Kimmerle. Castle Garden was in operation from 1855 to 1890 and was the first official Emigration Depot. This is why it's important to have narrow down the details of an ancestor's immigration, otherwise, you may be searching in a database that they will not be in. Read about where you ancestor could have possibly come through and where you would find those records here: Castle Garden or Ellis Island?

Search online databases:

Ellis Island New York Passenger Lists - Family Search.org

Family History Center Ellis Island - StatueOfLiberty.org

Castle Garden Database - CastleGarden.org

Immigration & Travel - Ancestry.com


As you can see, there are multiple options, databases, and helpful links that will lead you to possible manifests your ancestor may be listed on. The more information you can gather on an ancestor from multiple sources, the easier time you will have narrowing down the records you will need to look through. While this is not an extensive list of helpful tips, there are multiple sources online to help you. Check out some of the links below:

https://www.archives.gov/research/immigration/overview

https://stevemorse.org/ 

https://www.familysearch.org/wiki/en/US_Immigration_Passenger_Arrival_Records

https://youtu.be/Wqk08S7SajU
Video by Connie Knox – Genealogy TV 

https://youtu.be/taDG7nTqzl0
Video by Lisa Louise Cook

https://youtu.be/mhGvWwGOh1s
Video by Connie Knox – Genealogy TV

https://youtu.be/kXNFjJ3XlKA
Passport Applications - US National Archives

I hope this information has been helpful for you. If you have any suggestions or if you have any questions, leave them in the comments below.